Skip to main content

Review: The Diving Bell and the Butterfly by Jean-Dominique Bauby

 
Picture this: You go about your daily business as usual, doing the things you always like to do, and going to the places that you have always gone. Suddenly the whole world stops with a shudder as your muscles begin to fail you, and a searing headache accompanies the encroaching darkness as you black out. A stroke. Waking up, twenty days later, you find yourself unable to move at all. The doctors tell you that you have ‘locked-in syndrome’; you are effectively paralysed across your whole body. Your world has ended, you might think.
On 8 December 1995, this is what happened to Jean-Dominique Bauby, the then-editor-in-chief of French magazine Elle. Waking up in hospital in the northern French coastal town of Berck-sur-Mer, he found himself “paralysed from head to toe, his mind intact yet imprisoned inside his own body, unable to move or speak.” The only way he could communicate, or even move, is through the blinking of his left eyelid. Devastated, he discovered that he was, “exiled, paralysed, mute, half deaf, deprived of all pleasures and reduced to a jellyfish existence.”
Yet even despite such profound difficulties, Bauby was still able to create one of the most incredible achievements of modern literature. The Diving Bell and the Butterfly (1997) is a rare book in which the literary work itself is rivalled only by the effort made in writing it.  It was produced over the course of ten months entirely through blinking to an assistant, who translated it to page via an alphabet chart ordered according to letters’ frequency of use (one blink means ‘e’, two is ‘s’, and so on).
The result is a short, but perfectly formed novel, part memoir, part fantasy, which describes the comings and goings of his life since the catastrophic onset of his condition. Although the novel does have an overarching narrative of sorts- specifically about Bauby and his acclimatisation to his new life at the hospital- each chapter is a small vignette, which stands semi-autonomously on its own.

The Butterfly Escapes

Some of the novel’s chapters are personal, describing things such as the mundanities of his new life- being dressed, having visitors, visiting the beach with his assistant- but also his passions and past experiences, his family and his fear that in being ‘locked in’ in this way, people will forget the person that he is inside. His cruel detachment from the world has taken away so much from Bauby, yet left him fully aware of the things which he has lost. “Grief surges over me,” he despairs. “My son sits patiently waiting — and I, his father, have lost the simple right to ruffle his bristly hair, clasp his downy neck, hug his body tight against me.”
Others exist in the dreamlike realm of Bauby’s escapist fantasies, in which he can not only transcend his condition, but reality and time itself. In this world he can become a famous film director, constructing scenes from his favourite movies in his empty room; befriend the long-dead Empress Eugenie and share jokes with her; or even simply indulge in the memory of foods he can no longer eat. The hallway becomes a ballroom, the rehab room the Court of Miracles. “Since you never return to reality,” Bauby explains, “your dreams don’t have the luxury of evaporating. Instead, they pile up one upon another to form a long ongoing pageant whose episodes recur with the insistence of a soap opera.”



Triumph in Tragedy

Despite fundamentally being an introspective work at heart, Bauby’s journalistic flair shines through nevertheless. He speckles his work with morsels of information about the places and people he meets, taking a genuine interest in his surroundings, revealing the history of the hospital, of the people he meets, and even the names of paint colours.
Not only does it reveal the deepest passions of his life, but it also reflects a deep and humanistic sensibility in the man; it betrays his enduring humanity even throughout the most dehumanising of circumstances.
I should also note that at a very neat 139 pages, The Diving Bell and the Butterfly manages to achieve a rare thing in packing so much into so few pages. As far as deep and insightful works on the nature of the human condition go, this is by far the most readable and convenient for travel. Most chapters are only a few pages long, some only a page. If, in the age of coronavirus, you find yourself making a ‘necessary and essential journey’ anywhere, this is an ideal read.
Tragically, on 9 March 1997, two days after the book was published, Jean-Dominique Bauby died. Yet his novel remains a true example of triumph over hardship, and the ability to fight on despite one’s disabilities to create something wonderful. Beyond that of course, it is also simply an excellent book.


See more: Doom Eternal Review: Is It That Good? by Green Ornstein
Or explore more Living Prose here

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Carole and Tuesday vs. Kids on the Slope - Part 1.

Written by The Curmudgeon SPOILER WARNING: The following contains spoilers for both Carole and Tuesday and Kids on the Slope . Go watch them first if you don't want the plot spoiled. If you have seen them, or you just don't care, read on! I love Shinichiro Watanabe. I love ‘im. He’s responsible for some of my favourite things; from Cowboy Bebop  (1998)  – smart, sombre, and slick – to the utterly hilarious and bizarre Space Dandy  (2014) , he’s got a style that suits me just fine. Although it’s unlikely he’ll ever make something which moves me quite like Bebop , he always finds a way to imbue his work with such panache. Also, he wears sunglasses all the damn time. I’m not kidding, it’s actually challenging to find out what this man’s eyes look like. The problem is that he doesn’t helm too many original titles. As such, when Watanabe’s most recent series, Carole and Tuesday  (2019), debuted this year, it made some serious waves. Something about this...

How A Silent Voice changed my life - a salute to Kyoto Animation

Written by The Curmudgeon I n 2017 I watched a film for the first time which perfectly embodied my experience with depression. The story and themes captured not just the symptoms of my personal depression, but also a cause. It so succinctly sliced through the confusing bullshit of my mind. It cracked a code. I’m talking about  A Silent Voice   (2016) . I feel indebted to this movie because it somehow found a way to explain my depression better than I ever could. It gave me words when there were none. It made depression feel like a less lonely place, perhaps just because I had something to compare myself to. I’d like to delve into how the film affected me and how I read into it personally. This is not a review, nor is it an exhaustive essay claiming to understand what the film is ‘about’, per se. This is simply my own take on a film which affected me in a totally idiosyncratic way. And, as always…spoilers ahead. A Silent Voice revolves around two kids: a...

Porco Rosso - DISTANCE

Words by  Curmudgeon Film Talk There’s this scene in Porco Rosso (1992) wherein the protagonist, Marco, dines in solitude with his childhood friend, Gina. She relays a recently-acquired anecdote: a boisterous yet conceited seaplane pilot named Curtis - whom she’d just met - asked to marry her. “I’ve married three pilots,” she tells him, “one died in the war, one in the Atlantic, and the third in Asia.” I recall, upon watching Porco Rosso for the first time, this line irked me. “Here are two people who’ve been friends for many years. Why would she tell him this? Surely, he would already know,” I thought to myself. An excuse for exposition, I imagined. My criticism came too soon, though. As Marco hesitates, his face gone blank, it becomes clear – in the most indirect manner possible, Gina discloses her husband’s death. The solemn words follow: “they found him?” Their subdued manner keeps them composed. And yet, something in director Hayao Miyazaki’s detailed ey...